2014

Valentina Sánchez

4th Runner-up

2013

Christina Thompson

Top 16

2012

Kendal Barrett

2011

Savannah Schechter

Top 15

2010

Erica Szymanski

2009

Alexa Brunetti

2008

Michelle Leonardo

2007

Alyssa Campanella

1st Runner-up

2006

Julianna White

Top 10

2005

Regina Villano

2004

Rachael Carrollo

Top 10

2003

Jacklyn Pezzotta

4th Runner-up

2002

Sheri Drach

2001

Erin Abrahamson

2000

Ulrica Udani

1999

Nicole Marie Golas

1998

Melissa Dungao

1997

Lauren Petty

1996

Jessica Ponzo

1995

Joyce Houseknecht

1994

Kelli Paarz

Semi-Finalist

1993

Heather Brenner

1992

Lori Schmidt

1991

Kerri Paarz

1990

Jennifer Giordano

1989

Yvonne Christiano

1988

Michelle Knipfelberg

Semi-Finalist

1987

Tara Eldridge

1986

Rosalie Cuzo

Semi-Finalist

1985

Sharon Turner

1984

Tracy Grennon

1983

Sheri Drummond