2014

Emily Shah

Top 20

2013

Libell Duran

2012

Michelle Leonardo

Top 10

2011

Julianna White

2010

Chenoa Greene

2009

Kaity Rodriguez

2008

Tiffany Andrade

2nd runner-up

2007

Erin Abrahamson

2006

Jessica Boyington

2005

Sylvia Pogorzelski

2004

Janaye Ingram

2003

Vanessa Baker

2002

Robin Williams

2001

Jeannette Josue

2000

Michelle Graci

1999

Melissa McLaughlin

1998

Kelli Paarz

1997

Jennifer Makris

Top 10

1996

Christina Augustyn

1995

Christy Joy Pittner

1994

Rosa Velez

1993

Amy Fissel

Top 6

1992

Kathy Kasprak

1991

Charlotte Ray

1st runner-up

1990

Karin Hartz

2nd runner-up

1989

Deborah Lee Husti

2nd runner-up

1988

Colleen Carlone

1987

Stacey Fox

1986

Lisa Summeroury-Perry

1985

Francie Knapp

1984

Diane Everett Qualter

1983

Ann Marie Brucato

1982

Janice Lynn Straub

1981

Christy Garthwaite

1980

Joni Peifer

1979

Robin Senatore

1978

Sheryl Ann Hoehn

1977

Juanita McCarty

Semi-finalist

1976

Ginger Hagaman

1975

Cathy Russell

Semi-finalist

1974

Patricia Sims

1973

Patricia Everett

1972

Leila DeSantis

1971

Brenda Joyce White

1970

Ellen Cream

1969

Nancy Fromel

1968

Linda Papa

1967

Jean Galata

1966

Jo Ann Franchi

1965

Kay Franzen

1964

Barbara Joan Richartz

Semi-finalist

1963

Judy Kay Ayars

1962

Joyce Claire Thomson

1958

Faye Hasenauer

1957

Jeanne Lewis

1956

Dolores Winfield

Semi-finalist

1955

Beverly Rogers

1954

Evelyn Orowitz

Semi-finalist

1953

Susan Ruth Harris

1952

Ruth Jane Hampton

Top 10